Ultiworld Club Awards 2026: Defensive Player of the Year (Women’s Div.)

Whether layout blocks or shutdown defense, these players made life miserable for opposing offenses

Ultiworld is pleased to announce our annual Club Awards, starting with the First Team All-Club in each division. While we consider both regular season and postseason performance, because of the nature of the Club division, we weight success in the Series and at Nationals above all else. The Club Awards are voted on by Ultiworld reporters, contributors, and editors.

Our awards continue with the Defensive Player of the Year, recognizing the individual, and two runners-up, who we felt were the top defensive performers this club season. Whether through generating blocks, shutting down options, helping out teammates, or all of the above, these defenders stood out doing the tough work that too often go unrecognized.

All-Club First Team
Player of the Year Award
All-Club Second Team
Offensive Player of the Year Award
Defensive Player of the Year Award

Breakout Player of the Year Award
Coach(es) of the Year Award
Club Awards Voting Breakdown
Snubs and Superlatives


2026 Women’s Division Defensive Player of the Year

Kai Agueros (San Francisco Nightlock)

Nightlock’s Kai Agueros dives for a catch at the 2026 Club National Championships. Photo: Rodney Chen – UltiPhotos.com

The rise of Nightlock as a program was one of the best stories in the division this year, and so much of it comes down to players like Kai Agueros. While many of Nightlock’s other rookies can be lauded for their offensive efforts, no one stood out on the defensive end like Agueros. We all knew they’d be good after their time as a defensive menace at USC and UCSC, but the Nationals field is supposed to be an entirely different animal.

If the quality of competition mattered to Agueros, it didn’t show. They consistently read where their matchup was headed and beat them to the spot. Most great defenders get compared to predators, but Agueros played more like a shepherd: they guided the offense exactly where they wanted, then penned them in when the time was right. They would herd throwers toward the force and wait for any stray pass that might come their way.

The stats speak to their brilliance. By USAU’s count, no one recorded more blocks at Nationals than Agueros, and while a few players matched that total, the mix of precision and explosive power Agueros brought to their defense was in a class of its own. Counting Agueros’s blocks at Nationals is a bit like counting sheep… except the opposing team wasn’t getting any rest.

Defensive players are often harder to evaluate because of the playing time imbalance, but Agueros made such an impact every time they stepped on the field that they were impossible to ignore. Considering they were going up against the best offensive lines in the world, it says plenty that Agueros could make them look as meek as sheep.

– Graham Gerhart

First Runner-Up

Shayla Harris (San Francisco Fury)

Fury’s Shayla Harris gets a fingertip block over Brute Squad in the semifinal at the 2026 Club National Championships. Photo: Rodney Chen – UltiPhotos.com

Harris returns to the DPOTYium for the third time in three years, and once again as the runner-up. It’s hard to match Harris’ tenacity. There’s a certain doggedness that has always been a central component to Fury that Harris seems to embody on the field. It’s easy to say a player gives 110%, but Harris is one of the few to really earn that idiom. There’s always a bit extra from Harris, whether it is an aerial block where she elevates a bit higher, a full body layout she jumps for a bit earlier, or pulling the disc and setting the mark for the cup before her teammates get downfield.

Harris’ athleticism is just a piece of the puzzle, not the whole package. Smart, Harris uses her field awareness and game sense to shut down an under or break up a handler weave by poaching off and going just far enough to not get burned. And she does it all when the lights are brightest: her best game statistically was against eventual champions Brute Squad in the semifinal, where she was good for four blocks. 

– Zack Davis

Second Runner-Up

Kirstin Johnson (San Francisco Fury)

Fury’s Kirstin Johnson pulls at the 2026 Club National Championships. Photo: Sam Hotaling – UltiPhotos.com

Like so many other Fury players, it’s hard to evaluate the true impact of Kirstin Johnson’s game because the devil is in the detail. There’s not a lot of flash and style, no wasted motions, no christened moves she’s popularized. Instead, there’s hard work and effort. It’s the same qualities that put her in the OPOTY conversation and have set her as a DPOTY runner-up. There might be other players with the same skillset and talent as KJ, but they’re getting outworked by her year after year.

With so much of defense coming down to effort, it’s clear to see why KJ made the podium. On a team filled with players willing to give one hundred and ten percent, KJ finds a way to give a little more. Fury’s entire defensive approach is built around the team dynamic, so it’s hard to stand out on a team where 22 players recorded a block at Nationals… and you have teammate Shayla Harris as a defensive backbone. This season, KJ still found a way.

– Graham Gerhart

  1. Graham Gerhart
    Graham Gerhart

    Graham Gerhart is a Senior Staff Writer at Ultiworld, focusing primarily on the Women's and Mixed divisions. Graham graduated from the University of Cape Town in South Africa after playing 4 years with the UCT Flying Tigers. He now lives and works full time in San Diego. Follow him on Instagram @JustGrahamG

  2. Zack Davis
    Zack Davis

    Former D-III player for Spring Hill College, poached on the breakside. Follow on Bluesky if you want. @zackthescribe.bsky.social

TAGGED: , , , , , , , , , ,

TEAMS: ,

More from Ultiworld
Discussion on "Ultiworld Club Awards 2026: Defensive Player of the Year (Women’s Div.)"

Ultiworld is moving on from public comment sections as of 1/27/2025 (learn more about our decision here).

Want to talk about this article or anything else happening in the sport? Become a subscriber and join our Discord server!

Got a note or correction for our staff? Look for contact info on our About page.

We can also be reached on a variety of social media platforms; check out our header and footer for links to all of them.

Recent Events

Subscriber Exclusives

  • Inside The Circle: The Sheddies
    Subscriber podcast
  • The Best and Worst Jerseys of 2026 Club Championships
    Subscriber article
  • Out the Back: The Best and Worst
    Subscriber podcast
  • Deep Look LIVE: Club Player of the Year Announcements, All-Club
    podcast with bonus segment