Ultiworld Club Awards 2026: Breakout Player of the Year (Men’s Div.)

New stars are emerging in the men's division

Ultiworld is pleased to announce our annual Club Awards. While we consider both regular season and postseason performance, because of the nature of the Club division, we weight success in the Series and at Nationals above all else. The Club Awards are voted on by Ultiworld reporters, contributors, and editors.

Our Breakout Player of the Year may be the hardest-to-define award that we dole out each year. We aim to recognize players typically 25 years old or younger who weren’t widely expected to have a major impact on the club season at the start of the year. While their teammates or local community may have known about their talent level, their performance in the 2026 season thrust them into the national consciousness in a way that raises expectations for their contributions for years to come. Without strict parameters around what constitutes “too well known” at the start of the year, our voters are given the opportunity to decide for themselves who best represented their definition of a true breakout season in the club division.

All-Club First Team
Player of the Year Award
All-Club Second Team
Offensive Player of the Year Award
Defensive Player of the Year Award
Breakout Player of the Year Award
Coach(es) of the Year Award
Club Awards Voting Breakdown
Snubs and Superlatives


 

2026 Men’s Division Breakout Player of the Year

Alex Hall-Witt (Portland Rhino Slam!)

Alex Hall-Witt high fives Rhino Slam! teammate Joseph Marmerstein at the 2026 Club National Championships. Photo: Molly Bingham – UltiPhotos.com

Alex Hall-Witt started his spring by winning the college men’s Breakout Player of the Year, and he continued his meteoric rise by claiming the BPOTY on the club circuit following a simply outstanding season with semifinalists Portland Rhino Slam!

Hall-Witt, who didn’t notch an offensive stat at 2025 Nationals with Rhino, emerged as a key connective cutter for the Portland O-line early in the season, finding acres of open space with ease. He helped propel Rhino to their season-opening PEC West victory, and then the Oregon Ego star took another jump by leading a short-handed Rhino squad with 17 goals at the U.S. Open. There, Hall-Witt’s game-breaking speed became evident, as he was a routine deep threat for Rhino’s array of talented throwers.

At Nationals, Hall-Witt did it all again, as the world got to watch the emerging superstar torch elite defenders all over the San Diego sports complex. He peaked with his efforts under the brightest lights, a five goal effort in the semifinal against Machine in which Hall-Witt seemingly was always clear of his nearest defender by multiple yards. That punctuated a 12G/1A/5B effort in just five games for Hall-Witt.

As the five blocks may indicate, Hall-Witt wasn’t just a one-trick rhino either. Not only did Hall-Witt frequently help the O-line earn the disc back when needed, he was one of two Portland players (alongside POTY-runner up Mica Glass) who crossed over prior to universe point as Rhino sought to claw back a late-game break against Machine. He also played on universe point and notched a block.

Hall-Witt’s rise from sparely-played role player to integral two-way star and goal-scoring machine for one of the premier men’s programs in the country earns him Breakout Player of the Year honors for the second time in 2026. Safe to say, Hall-Witt won’t be sneaking up on anyone, in college or club, in 2027.

– Aidan Thomas

First Runner-Up

Stefan McCall (Atlanta Chain Lightning)

Chain Lightning’s Stefan McCall makes an acrobatic catch over the Truck Stop defender in the 2026 Pro Championships quarterfinal. Photo: Kevin Leclaire – UltiPhotos.com

Stefan McCall came into 2026 being an (almost) true rookie to club, yet still managed to find himself smashing any expectations one may have about a first trip to the Club Championships.

McCall played with a poise well beyond his years, finding himself on the field in the most essential moments as a key contributor on offensive possessions. Scrambling into tight spaces, McCall dynamically opened downfield space and punctuated possessions all season long. Frequently drawing difficult matchups, McCall proved he’s the real deal even outside of a college setting, beating his own college nationals statline with his club performance of 15G/10A/1B.

Proving himself as a club star, Stefan McCall is sure to have an impressive 2027 run following his breakout performance on the biggest stage.

– Nate Knowles

Second Runner-Up

Will Selfridge (Atlanta Chain Lightning)

Chain Lightning’s Will Selfridge at the 2026 Club National Championships. Photo: Sam Hotaling – UltiPhotos.com

Rounding out the BPotY-ium is the other half of Chain Lightning’s one-two punch duo, Will Selfridge. The do-it-all machine found himself with his best club season to date, proving himself as far more than the threatening cutter he is known to be.

Beginning as a downfield initiator, Selfridge was essential to the connection between cutters and the backfield, with his dynamic arsenal opening continuations for a smooth offense. As the connecting piece, Selfridge’s presence and patience helped control the tempo of an offense split between styles.

Showing a repertoire of high speed throw-and-go offense, alongside patient distribution, Selfridge was the key to many of Chain Lightning’s successes. Completing a team-high 22 assists, good for third in the division, Selfridge certainly earned his breakout and will be a defining presence wherever he appears next.

– Nate Knowles

  1. Aidan Thomas
    Aidan Thomas

    Aidan is from Maine and grew up with eight siblings. He began playing ultimate in college with Notre Dame Papal Rage until he graduated in 2023. He played with MOB Ultimate in Baltimore for four seasons and now lives in Virginia, writing on frisbee + other high school and college sports.

  2. Nate Knowles
    Nate Knowles

    Nate Knowles is a Club Men's writer from Lexington, Kentucky. He is currently a student at the University of Kentucky, studying architecture and playing with Kentucky KULT. He loves talking about ultimate and can be reached via email ([email protected]).

TAGGED: , , , , , , , , , ,

TEAMS: ,

More from Ultiworld
Discussion on "Ultiworld Club Awards 2026: Breakout Player of the Year (Men’s Div.)"

Ultiworld is moving on from public comment sections as of 1/27/2025 (learn more about our decision here).

Want to talk about this article or anything else happening in the sport? Become a subscriber and join our Discord server!

Got a note or correction for our staff? Look for contact info on our About page.

We can also be reached on a variety of social media platforms; check out our header and footer for links to all of them.

Recent Events

Subscriber Exclusives

  • Deep Look LIVE: Club Awards, Ring of Fire Coach David Allison
    podcast with bonus segment
  • Inside The Circle: The Sheddies
    Subscriber podcast
  • The Best and Worst Jerseys of 2026 Club Championships
    Subscriber article
  • Out the Back: The Best and Worst
    Subscriber podcast